You can buy the Cougar for $399 right now at Academy, that's NIB. You can't run out and buy the Security Six. The way I look at it is, your Cougar is worth less than $400...add $200 for the .40 cal ammo(prob. more these days) and you have $600 on your side.
He is offering the Security Six and $150 which sounds like a pretty fair trade for both of you. That SS is worth $450-500 these days, add the $150 cash and you have a value of $600-650.
I would go with the Ruger, you can always buy another Cougar.
View the original article here